Skip To Main Content

Binghamton University Athletics

Two of a Kind
Jelani Pusey

Two of a Kind

| By:

Local running standouts Schaffer and Mackay leaving a legacy at BU

The first time Emily Mackay and Dan Schaffer were classmates, they were too young to remember it. During the 2003-04 school year, they were in the same kindergarten class at Maine Memorial School, which is located in the Binghamton area.

From there, the two of them grew up in separate school districts. Mackay graduated from Union-Endicott High School in 2016 while Schaffer graduated from Maine-Endwell High School that same year. Since they were both standouts in track & field and cross country, they knew of each other but never really got a chance to get to know each other.

Following high school graduation, Schaffer and Mackay went their separate ways. While Schaffer stayed local and attended Binghamton University, Mackay headed out to Oregon State University. Each of them planned on continuing their running careers in college.

Today, Mackay and Schaffer are more than just classmates at Binghamton University. They are longtime teammates on the Bearcat track and cross country program and are linked together as two of the most prolific distance runners in Binghamton program history. Each of them have overcome more than their share of obstacles along the way and have been a source of support for each other as their careers have blossomed. 

Beginnings

Kindergarten 2003-04Up until a year ago, Schaffer and Mackay didn't know that they were in the same kindergarten class. That was until Mackay was going through her yearbook to find a photo of someone else.

"I was going through the yearbook from kindergarten looking for someone else's photo when I saw Dan's photo and realized that we were classmates," she said. "I was surprised."

"When Emily told me we were classmates in kindergarten, I had to dig up my old yearbook to see it for myself," Schaffer said. "I didn't remember that."

When Schaffer and Mackay were in high school, however, they definitely became aware of each other. Union-Endicott and Maine-Endwell form one of the biggest high school rivalries in the local Binghamton area. In both track and cross country, the two schools compete against each other at the conference, sectional and state levels. 

Mackay was named All-New York State (NYS) twice in cross country at Union-Endicott and set the New York State Section 4 track & field records in the 1,500 and 3.000. She also qualified for the Nike Cross Country National Meet during her career.

"Although we never met, I certainly knew who Emily was," Schaffer said. "Most memorably, I watched her race in the 1,500 championship at the 2015 New York State Meet. It was the most exciting race of the day where she ran a huge personal best, narrowly finishing second."

Schaffer, meanwhile, was named All-NYS three times in cross country during his career at Maine-Endwell and also qualified for the Nike National Meet. In 2016, he won the New York State Federation track & field title in the mile. 

"I knew that Dan was fast just by watching him race," Mackay said. "But I wasn't paying attention to other runners' times like I do now. I just knew he was very good at running."

What Schaffer and Mackay had in common besides being fast was how they got their start in running – by trying to stay in shape to be better at soccer when they were in middle school.

"My soccer coaches told me I was fast and I might be good at track so I figured I would give it a try," Mackay said. "I started off doing hurdles and shorter events and didn't start middle distance running until high school."
Schaffer NLI
"I decided to join the modified track and field team in the spring to stay in shape for soccer," Schaffer said. "Naturally, I was drawn to the distance events, and even ran some local 5K road races over the summer with my longtime friend and teammate, Grayson Hoteling."

When it came time to choose a college, however, Mackay and Schaffer went their separate ways. Schaffer became familiar with the Bearcat program during high school but that wasn't the case for Mackay. Eventually, Mackay headed out to Oregon State while Schaffer arrived in Vestal in the fall of 2016.

"Back in high school, I didn't really know much about Binghamton's program." Mackay said.

"I first became aware of Binghamton when I heard about Jesse Garn being an All-American (in 2015)," Schaffer said. "But it wasn't until the recruiting period began that I really found out how successful the program was."

Battling Injuries

Schaffer's career at Binghamton started off with him redshirting during the entire 2016-17 academic year. Although he was not able to compete for the Bearcats, he still remembers that year fondly.

"Despite redshirting my entire first year, I still had the opportunity to travel and race," he said. "Some of my fellow freshmen and some upperclassmen were also redshirting so we traveled together to compete unattached and to cheer on our teammates at meets. Although it was hard to sit out the entire year, I made some great memories traveling and racing unattached."

The future looked bright for Schaffer but a series of injuries - starting in the fall of 2017 - hindered his performances. He had some significant races, such as earning runner up honors at the 2018 America East Cross Country Championships, but spent several other seasons fighting an assortment of physical setbacks. His biggest injury came at the end of his junior year.

Emily Mackey"In 2019, I injured the sesamoid bone in my foot and was told I would need surgery to fix it," he said. "It was scary to find out I needed surgery on my foot, not to mention the required two plus months of recovery, rehab and no running. That was the toughest setback I have experienced in my career."

Mackay too redshirted during her freshman year at Oregon State but she struggled with injuries right off the bat. In the summer of 2017, she decided to come back home and enroll at Binghamton University. At the time, she was at a low point both physically and emotionally.

"After not running much for almost a year, I was out of shape and basically starting completely from the beginning when I started training under coach (Annette) Acuff," she said. "When I came to Binghamton, I was feeling discouraged but not ready to give up on running."

Mackay struggled to regain her form from her high school career. For the first few years at Binghamton, her times were not as fast as they were at Union-Endicott.

"It was hard to stay motivated at times," she said. "There were times that I questioned whether I would ever be able to run those times again. Coach Acuff helped me to trust the process by constantly reminding me that it takes time build back endurance and strength after taking so much time off. Coach Acuff believed in me and that helped to me believe in myself."

As Schaffer began to get back into shape following his 2019 injury, he too found encouragement from his coaching staff.

"I am so grateful for my head coach Annette Acuff and her support during that time," he said. "I am also appreciative of Chris Downey and the sports medicine staff, who organized my rehabilitation plan, and for assistant coach Patrick Murray, and his guidance (and company) in cross training. I came back running stronger and faster than ever thanks to their support."

Going on Pause

During the 2020 indoor track season, both Mackay and Schaffer finally were in a good point in their careers. Mackay anchored the first-place 4x800 relay team at the America East Championships while Schaffer clocked a four-minute mile (4:00.38) in his final meet of the season. Each of them was primed for a stellar outdoor campaign when the COVID-19 pandemic brought everything to a halt on March 12, 2020.

Dan Schaffer"Right before the pandemic hit, I was finally starting to see some success in the mile which was very exciting to me because the 1,500 was my best distance in high school," Mackay said. "I thought that if I could get back to running close to what I was running in high school that would be the start of finally feeling like I am making progress towards my goals."

"The pandemic ended the track season in 2020 just as I was hitting my stride," Schaffer said. "The last race I ran was the four-minute mile at the Boston University Last Chance Meet, where I had the opportunity to race some of my idols in the sport."

The pandemic forced Mackay and Schaffer to find different ways to stay in shape but each successfully made the adjustment.

"What kept me going during the pandemic was knowing that it was the perfect opportunity to focus more on myself and my goals for running - which were to be consistent and stay healthy," Mackay said. "I knew if I could do both of those things, I would see improvement."

"Having just missed breaking the four-minute mark in my final meet is what motivated me during the pandemic," Schaffer said. "It made me hungrier than before and I knew how grateful I would be when we were finally able to compete again."

Breakthroughs

When college sports resumed during the 2020-21 academic year, both Mackay and Schaffer finally experienced career-defining performances.

For Mackay, it happened during the cross country season, which took place that February and March. She won the America East title and earned an automatic bid to the NCAA Championships, which she placed 14th overall. In the process, she was named Binghamton's first-ever NCAA Division I cross country All-American

"That cross country season was when I knew that all my hard work over the last year paid off and was going to pay off more than I even imagined," she said. "It was then that I knew that it was just the beginning for me and that I was far from done with my running career."

Mackay then followed up with a seventh-place finish in the 5,000-meter race at the NCAA Outdoor Track & Field Championships to clinch another All-America honor.

Emily Mackay"I gained momentum from having the race of my life at cross country NCAAs but I knew it was definitely not going to be easy to try to top that performance in outdoors," she said. "At the Outdoor NCAA meet, I was feeling unusually fatigued half way through the race but since it was it was such an important race, I was able to push through."

Schaffer, meanwhile, finally was able to break the four-minute mile mark, running 3:58.48 at the Toledo Rocket Invitational last May. It was a moment he had been aiming for through injuries and the pandemic.

"It was a feeling of disbelief," he said. "After narrowly missing the sub four-minute mile mark a couple times, I did not believe it when saw 3:58 on the clock as I crossed the finish line. I was thrilled to have achieved such a huge milestone in my career and to follow in the footsteps of (former Binghamton runners) Erik Van Ingen, Jesse Garn, and Eric Holt in Binghamton history."

This past October, Schaffer was finally able check off another of his career goals – winning the America East cross country title. In the two seasons since his second-place finish in 2018, injuries had kept that from becoming a reality.

"After placing second at the America East Championships in 2018, I set my sights on winning the title that next year," he said. "However, in each of the following two years, injuries kept me from competing at my best. It was very special to finally achieve that goal this past fall and win a cross country title."

What made the win all the more special to Schaffer was that Mackay repeated as the women's champion in the same meet. Together, they became the first men's and women's runners from the same school to sweep the America East individual titles since 1991.

"Emily winning the women's title made the day twice as sweet," he said. "I was equally as excited and proud to see my friend and teammate achieve her goal that day too. It was very special to make history with Emily."

Mackay had similar sentiments from that historic day.

"Watching Dan win his race was incredibly exciting as well, especially knowing how long he's had the goal to win the conference title," Mackay said. "The fact we were both able to do it the same year made it extra special and it was definitely a day I will never forget."

Looking Ahead and Looking Back

Both Mackay and Schaffer are in the middle of the final indoor and outdoor track & field seasons of their illustrious careers. Both of them show no signs of slowing down. Mackay has posted the top women's mile time in the nation and Schaffer has broken the four-minute mile mark twice more. Both will enter the America East Indoor Meet as favorites to win whichever events they enter.

As of February 2022, Mackay owns seven Binghamton school records, has won five conference titles, advanced to three NCAA Championship meets and is a two-time All-American. Schaffer, meanwhile, has also won five career America East titles and has broken a pair of school records. Each of them has also received numerous academic awards during their careers.

Rumble PoniesSchaffer and Mackay will leave Binghamton in the spring with both their bachelors and master's degrees in the spring but there is much more they still want to accomplish on the track. Still, both of them can look back on their years at Binghamton University as a defining time of their lives.

"I have had so many amazing experiences and opportunities at Binghamton and I've received all the support that I needed in order to be successful," Mackay said, "I also learned good habits from my teammates throughout the years which I am so thankful for. I feel so lucky to have had such great leaders throughout my first few years at Binghamton who taught me what it means to be dedicated to both running and academics and how to be a leader myself."

"It has been a privilege to be a student-athlete here at Binghamton the past several years," Schaffer said, "I've had the opportunity to meet so many different people and to learn so many new concepts. I have been challenged every day both in the classroom and on the track."

Above all else, Schaffer and Mackay have gone from not remembering they were kindergarten classmates and not knowing each on a personal level during high school to becoming close friends during college. Together, they have developed into two of the most accomplished local high school standouts ever to have made their mark at Binghamton University. Through the years, their mutual respect has grown stronger.

"I most admire and respect Emily's exceptional patience, perseverance and strength," Schaffer said. "She faced her own adversity transitioning from high school to college and easily could have become frustrated with the sport after struggling to match her high school times. Instead, I've watched her patiently chip away and steadily make improvements year after year."

"Dan is one of the most hard-working and kind people I know," Mackay said. "I have gotten to know Dan pretty well this past year since we started meeting up to do workouts together during breaks. Being around Dan at practice, during workouts and at meets motivates me because we are both working towards similar goals. Seeing Dan's commitment and dedication to running has always been inspiring to me."

FURTHER READING:

Schaffer Earns Top-40 Ranking in US Track & Field News (March 31, 2020)
Schaffer Reflects on COVID-19 Shutdown (April 14, 2020)
Mackay Earns Cross Country All-America Honors (March 15, 2021)
Schaffer Breaks Four-Minute Mile Mark (May 15, 2021)
Mackay Earns First-Team Track & Field All-America Honors (June 12, 2021)
Mackay and Schaffer Earn COSIDA All-Academic Honors (July 15, 2021)
Mackay Named Academic All-American (August 12, 2021)
Schaffer and Mackay Throw Out First Pitch at Rumble Ponies Game (August 5, 2021)
Mackay and Wrestler Lou DePrez Honored by BU Athletic Department as All-Americans (Sept. 13, 2021)
Mackay and Schaffer Sweep America East Cross Country Titles (Oct. 29, 2021)
Schaffer and Mackay Sweep Mile Titles at Penn State National Open (Jan. 22, 2022)
Mackay Clocks NCAA-Best 4:30 Mile (Feb. 11, 2022)
 
 
 
Print Friendly Version

Related Videos

Related Stories

Skip Ad

Sponsors

Skip Sponsors